Your broker shows up once a year with a renewal letter and a summary report. The renewal letter has a number. The summary report has a chart. Neither one has been audited. Neither one has been priced. Neither one has been marked to market.
That is not actuarial work. That is paperwork dressed up as analysis.
You have been paying a percentage of premium — every month, every year, for the entire history of your relationship with that broker — for a service that does not include actuarial pricing of the position you are holding. You have been billed for procurement and told it was governance.
The reason none of this work gets done is structural. The broker who renews your plan was not trained as an actuary, was not trained as an underwriter, and is not credentialed to price the position they sold you. You are paying a percentage of premium for procurement and being told it is governance. That is not a personal failure of any one broker. It is the design of the model.